2007 Buty Winery Columbia Rediviva Phinny Hill Vineyard
Estimated value
Buying options
Tasting notes
The berries that informed his Cabernet-Syrah 2007 Columbia Rediviva Phinny Hill Vineyard were so tiny, notes Foster, that extraction proceeded much more quickly than usual and he pressed within 12 days, letting the fermentation finish in barrel. One certainly seems to taste that tiny-berry concentration. Bitter-edged cassis, huckleberry, and seedy black raspberry; green herbs; sprouting lentil; and walnut inform a firm, finely-tannic palate and this finishes with a remarkable sense of focus, energy and lift for a tannic wine of its two cepages, not to mention of 14.5% alcohol. Suggestions of stone and iodine add to the complexity on display here, though, interestingly, – as with the other installments of this cuvee I tasted – the Syrah doesn’t display any of its animal side. Like its 2007 counterpart, this became more intriguing as it opened to air. I see no reason not to anticipate at least another 4-5 years of fascination. Buty is the project, begun in 2000, of Zelma Long protegee and veteran Washington winemaker Caleb Foster with his wife Nina Buty Foster. While their only public facility is located in Walla Walla and they recently bottled the first wine from their estate on the famously cobbled nearby soils of Milton-Freewater (a project on which Foster’s viticultural go-to guy, Phil Freese, consulted), most of their fruit is sourced from farther west, for red wine notably from the Beightol family’s impressive and manifestly impeccably-farmed Phinny Hill Vineyard whose slopes overlook the immediately adjacent and much more famous Champoux Vineyard that Dick Beightol helped plant and managed in its years as part of the surrounding Mercer Ranch. Foster, incidentally, reports very seldom adding tartaric acid to any of his musts, white or red; yet brightness and juiciness characterize most of the wines I tasted on my first visit with him. For reds – portions of which ferment in wooden uprights – he utilizes various means of extraction, including air-injection. Beast represents a parallel label to Buty (hence the prefacing of those wines descriptions with “Beast;” but reference to Buty does not appear on their labels.). Tel. (509) 527-0901
Critic scores
Average Score
Stephen Tanzer, Vinous
Jeb Dunnuck
More reviews and scores
A smoking good wine, the 2007 Buty Columbia Rediviva Phinny Hill Vineyard, a blend of 52% Syrah and 48% Cabernet Sauvignon, delivers an awesome aromatic display of leafy tobacco, fresh crushed stone, black currant, chocolate, and beautiful background floral nuances that lend complexity, lift and vibrancy. Very Bordeaux like with its edge of wood and firm structure, the wine is full bodied on the palate and perfectly put together, displaying ripe, focused fruit, a seamless, silky texture, solid structure, and an excellent finish. I’m a big fan and this rock star wine should continue to evolve for 3-4 years and drink well for a decade afterwards, if not longer.
Bright medium ruby. Cherry, spices and dusty cocoa powder on the nose, along with a whiff of musky woodsmoke. Lush, silky and rich, with a strong mocha oak component adding to the impression of sweetness, but this shows better mid-palate definition and less of a liqueur character than the Champoux Vineyard blend. Finishes with building, palate-dusting tannins.