2011 Yattarna
Estimated value
Buying options
Tasting notes
The year Shaw + Smith bought Tolpuddle vineyard. Savoury nose. Mouth-filling, with real drive. Lots of impact here and a proper beginning, middle and end. Very long. (JR)
Critic scores
Average Score
Julia Harding MW, jancisrobinson.com
Richard Hemming MW, jancisrobinson.com
More reviews and scores
I was taken aback by the youthfulness of this precise, smoky wine that tucked pure, long, citrus lines into its hazelnut-savoury, roasted-honeyed-oats frame. Cut-glass acidity that seems to fragment the light and emphasise the compact yet fine depth of the fruit. I would love to have tasted this wine in a situation where I could be a bit more focused on it – there was a very distracting presentation going on and nowhere to write tasting notes. But it struck me that it wasn't unlike a grand cru Montrachet. (TC)
Much more vegetal notes and cooked fruit than the 2018. Broad, fleshy palate with grip and texture. Lingering mealy note – loads of persistence here, with a long smoky finish right at the end. (RH)
Launched in 1998 with the 1995 vintage, Yattarna is intended to be a white wine that stands alongside the standard of Grange. An evolving style but focused on cool-climate fruit, though the source may change from year to year because the aim is for a 'house style'. 2011 was good on Tasmania, where most of the fruit originates, more challenging in the Adelaide Hills. TA 6.7 g/l, pH 3.15. Fermented and aged in 100% French oak barriques (64% new – though this is always vintage dependent). We have 'Come a long way with oak selection', says Gago. Gently mealy oak aroma but subtle. There's a hint of orange pith and grapefruit and even ginger – lovely refined complexity. Lightly spiced, slightly toasty/smoky but not especially reductive. Hint of hazlenuts. Beautifully shaped and dense but still has that cool-climate freshness. Very crisp acidity and pure piercing citrus on the plate. Very long. Very citrusy on the mid palate, leaner and more refined than Bin A Chardonnay. (JH)
About the producer

Penfolds is Australia’s most famous wine producer, known best for their iconic top wine, Grange. First produced commercially in 1952, Grange has since gone on to become one of the world’s most famous fine wines. In 2001, the wine was listed as an Australian heritage icon.