2007 Puligny Montrachet Les Combettes
Estimated value
Buying options
Tasting notes
The Girardin 2007 Puligny-Montrachet Les Combettes adds musk melon to the predictable repertoire of peach and lemon, offering an especially flatteringly creamy texture that – as with other of the best 2007s – by no means precludes vivacity or refreshment. Wafting floral perfume and underlying nut oil and malt richness contribute to the allure. But there is plenty of mineral depth here, too – suggestive inter alia of oyster liquor and shrimp shell – that sets up a dynamic interaction with the wine's abundant fruit. This finishes with a tug on the salivary glands, stomach, and imagination alike. I would anticipate close to a decade's intrigue and enjoyment, perhaps more. Girardin is keen to emphasize his being the sold proprietor with more than one parcel in Combettes, as he believes the two he owns – at the northern and southern extremes of the site – offer unique complementarity. Vincent Girardin picked until past mid-September, with most of his top sites being brought in only from the 10th; allowed skin contact he would have avoided until recent years; and beat the lees on his young wines only until Christmas, but then bottled – with a light fining, and in many instances no filtration – only in May, 2009 to maximize passive time on the lees. The regimen of new wood here (now 20-30% depending on cru) represents a drastic diminution in just the past several years, and the 2007s strike me as far more comfortable in their skins than those of 2004-2006, benefiting also from the freshness and vivacity that characterize the vintage. He picked a week too late in 2006, opines Girardin with hindsight, but then, this was almost unavoidable in at least some instances for a vintner with such huge acreage. Girardin finds his 2007s especially marked by the typicity of each individual site, not only to a greater degree than in the two more obviously ripe preceding vintages, but also than in 2008. This is an aspect he is convinced will gradually be enhanced by a conversion to biodynamic methods that is underway. Girardin's 2007 musts were selectively chaptalized and finished wines here are largely in the vicinity of 13% alcohol. As usual, given the vast array of estate and negociant wines at this address (the latter status noted, where applicable, in my texts), I was not able to take time for tasting them all; in particular omitting the generics. Importer: Vineyard Brands, Birmingham, AL; tel. (205) 980-8802
Critic scores
Average Score
Jancis Robinson MW
Stephen Tanzer, Vinous
More reviews and scores
(bottled at the beginning of May '09) Pale, bright yellow. Pretty, expressive aromas of yellow fruits, nut oil, flowers and coconut. Ripe, sweet and rather powerfully built, with penetrating acidity framing the concentrated, tactile peach and brown spice flavors. Wonderfully intense and high-pitched Puligny with a very long and sappy mineral-driven back end. Girardin referred to this tangy beauty as the best wine in the cellar in 2007.
Mineral nose. Interesting textured palate. Bone dry but, unlike the Folatières, there seems to be enough fruit here. Really rather impressive. Good beginning, middle and end to this wine. You could drink it now but it would be a bit of a shame. (JR)
(racked) Crystallized peach, minerals and spices on the nose. Sweet and spicy but less open and opulent than the Folatieres. But this too is quite broad and round, and offers terrific palate coverage and length.